How to Ask for a Raise: Build the Case First

By Andy · October 25, 2026 · About a 4-minute read

You’ve been doing great work, and your pay hasn’t kept up. Learning how to ask for a raise starts with a simple truth: asking works more often than people expect. In a 2024 LendingTree survey (opens in a new tab) of about 2,000 U.S. adults, 82% of full-time workers who asked for a raise said they received one. That’s no guarantee for you, but it’s a good reason not to stay quiet.

I’ve written performance reviews and built pay cases as a manager. The asks that got taken seriously had two things in common.

1. A short case, not a long list

The strongest cases weren’t a list of everything someone did. They were a handful of things that mattered to the business, like time saved, money saved, or a problem solved, each with a clear “so what.” A short case is easier for your manager to carry to the people who approve pay.

2. No surprises

By the time someone asked, I already knew the story, because they’d been mentioning their wins in our regular one-on-ones (1:1s) all along. And those wins weren’t just personal achievements. They were milestones that moved our team’s strategy forward. When an ask comes out of nowhere, a manager has to start from scratch. When it’s been building for months, it’s already half made.

Know your pay range before you ask

Come in with data, not a hunch. Find the pay range for your role if your company shares it, and figure out roughly where your salary sits in it. Someone low in the range with a strong track record has a very different conversation than someone near the top.

What the easiest raises had in common

The easiest raises and promotions I supported went to people who were doing the hard things, visibly, and succeeding, or at least making very noticeable progress. By the time their name came up, their reputation was already well known. What’s written on the HR form matters. But what made those cases easy was value-add work that lined up with my team’s goals and the company’s.

Turning it into the conversation

Knowing what makes a case strong is the first step. Building it, planning the conversation, knowing what to say, and knowing what to do if you hear “not yet” is the work. My From Doing the Work to Being Known for It kit walks you through it with the Promotion Packet, the Meeting With Your Manager Template, and the Compensation Conversation Planner. Many employers have learning budgets, so check whether yours covers it.

Start free: my Know Your North Star worksheet helps you check whether a raise is the thing you want most right now.

FAQ

When is the best time to ask for a raise?

After you’ve laid the groundwork in regular conversations, and ideally before your company makes its review and pay decisions. Ask your manager when those decisions happen.

Will asking for a raise hurt my relationship with my manager?

Not when it’s done respectfully and backed by a clear case. Good managers expect career conversations. What strains a relationship is an ask that comes out of nowhere, which is why the groundwork matters.

This article shares my own experience and is meant to educate and encourage, not to serve as legal, financial, or employment advice. Nothing here can promise a raise or promotion. See my Disclaimer.