How to Negotiate a Job Offer: What to Ask For and When

By Andy · October 25, 2026 · About a 4-minute read

An offer just landed, and now you’re deciding whether to ask for more. If you’re wondering how to negotiate a job offer without putting it at risk, start here: a respectful, well-reasoned counteroffer is a normal part of hiring. I’ve been the hiring manager on the other side of these conversations, and the candidates who negotiated well didn’t push harder. They prepared better.

What to ask for

Start with what matters most to you, not what you think you’re supposed to ask for. For most people, base salary comes first, because it’s the value that every raise in the future will build on. But it isn’t the only lever. Paid time off, flexibility, and the kind of work you’ll do can matter just as much, depending on where you are in life. If you’re not sure what you want most, my free Know Your North Star worksheet helps you rank it before the offer arrives.

How much to ask for

Pick a number you can justify. Stay inside the posted range, and don’t open at the very top unless your experience clearly backs it up. Asking for the top with nothing behind it is one of the fastest ways to stall a negotiation. At the same time, don’t sell yourself short: research what the role pays, look honestly at what you bring, and land on a number you can explain in a sentence or two.

When to ask

Timing matters more than most people realize. Don’t negotiate before the interview or during it; your job then is to show you’re the right fit. If a recruiter asks your salary expectations early, it’s fine to say you’re comfortable within the posted range. The time to negotiate is after the offer, once they’ve decided they want you.

What happens after you ask

Most candidates never see this part. Your counteroffer usually goes from the recruiter to the hiring manager, and Human Resources (HR) often checks it against people already in similar roles. That’s why a calm ask with a clear reason works better than a big number with no explanation. You’re giving everyone involved a reason to say yes.

What I saw from the hiring side

When I was the hiring manager, the candidates who were easy to say yes to had a few things in common. Their asks were concise, and every one came with a reason I could verify. That justification mattered most: they had to be worth what they were asking for. They responded quickly, so the process kept moving. And they treated it as a two-way conversation. I wanted them, they wanted the job, and we were working together on the best outcome available. They also remembered that the negotiation builds on everything that came before it, from the job posting to the interview. It doesn’t throw any of that out the window.

The hard ones were the opposite: slow or no responses, a counter at the very top of the posted range with nothing to back it up, or a case built on something that was hard to see on the résumé and never came up in the interview. If something matters to your number, make sure it’s something the hiring team has already seen.

The “how” lives in the kit

Knowing what and when is half of it. The other half is the words: what to write, how to justify your number, and how to handle a second round. That’s what my Your Climb Starts Here kit is for, with the Email Template for Negotiations, Know Your North Star, and the Job Search Tracker and Pros/Cons Worksheet for comparing offers side by side.

Not ready for a kit? Start with the free worksheet.

FAQ

Is it okay to negotiate an entry-level offer?

Yes. Keep it respectful and stay within the posted range. Even if salary doesn’t move, other parts of the offer may.

Should I negotiate by email or by phone?

Either works. Use whichever helps you stay calm and clear.

This article shares my own experience and is meant to educate and encourage, not to serve as legal, financial, or employment advice. Nothing here can promise a specific outcome. See my Disclaimer.